Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Dip

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.


In some ways I was very excited to test this pin. I mean, who doesn’t like Reese’s? (I know there are people who are horribly allergic to peanut butter, and I mean no disrespect.) I was bringing this to a potluck to honor a friend whose favorite candy was Reese’s, but more about that later. On to the test.

This is the original pin from Aimee of Shugary Sweets .

The ingredients were easy to find – even the mini Reese’s.

Almost all Ingredients


Melt the butter and brown sugar in a pan over medium heat.

Butter & Brown Sugar


Whisk and bring to a boil.

Whisk together

Read the instructions and realize you were in a hurry and almost forgot the peanut butter.

Ingredients with PB

Add peanut butter and vanilla to the boiling butter/brown sugar mixture.

Bring to boil & add PB and Vanilla

Remove from heat and whisk to smooth it out.

Off heat and whisk

The recipe says to cool to almost room temperature. So I set it aside while I mixed the cream cheese and powdered sugar.

Cream cheese & Powdered Sugar

After about 5 minutes I went to check the cooling peanut butter mixture… not what I expected.

Let cool

The butter separated while it had cooled and no amount of mixing and whisking would bring it back together. Nothing was mentioned about this, so I carried on as if this was normal.

Add PB mixture


I added the peanut butter mixture to the cream cheese mixture. After a few minutes, it did seem to smooth out.

Mix together WM

I added the chips and mini Reese’s cups. Can I say how thankful that I am to NOT have to unwrap and chop a bunch of full-sized candies? Thank you Hershey’s!

Stir in CC & PBC

The dip seemed a bit soft, so I put it in the fridge to chill out while I got ready for the potluck.


After about 40 minutes, the consistency definitely improved. I put it into two containers and went to the event where it was served with graham crackers and Keebler Flip Sides pretzel crackers and got good reviews.

After refrigerating

I think my friend would have liked this dip very much, however the potluck was a Celebration of Life so she wasn’t able to give a personal opinion. But she knew that my way to honor someone was with a home-made gift of love from my kitchen. So this one’s for you, JCC. We’ll always love and miss you.


The Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Dip rated as follows:

Overall Rating: 4 Pins

4 Pins Overall

Accuracy: Much of the recipe came together very easily, as I had expected. However, the separating of the butter after the peanut butter mixture cooled was a bit unnerving – especially due to the nature of the event. My finished dip didn’t turn out quite as fluffy as the original picture, either. It tasted good, but 4 pins.

Rated 4 Pins - SMALL

Difficulty: While not difficult, an inexperienced cook might have been put off by the butter separation and quit. (That’s the last I’m going to say about that subject.) 4 pins.

Rated 4 Pins - SMALL

Time: Adding in the 40 minutes of chilling while I was getting ready, the dip came together in less than an hour. Good time for something tasty. 5 pins

Rated 5 Pins - SMALL

Cost: I had everything on hand except the mini chocolate chips and mini Reese’s, which were less than $3.00 each. 5 pins

Rated 5 Pins - SMALL

Practicality: This was tasty and would be a nice addition to any party table. 5 pins

Rated 5 Pins - SMALL


Pinterest addict, award-winning baker, and cookbook contributor - I'm Anne and I'm so glad that you've found Pintesting. This is where we test, review, and rate Pinterest pins on a weighted 5-point scale and sometimes share our own recipes, tips, and tricks.

1 thought on “Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Dip”

  1. I’m sorry about the loss of your friend. I hope the time that has passed has eased the pain.
    I just wanted to mention that the peanut butter was supposed to be mixed into the cream cheese, not the boiling butter/sugar mixture. I made it yesterday and didn’t have any problems with separation. I’m glad yours still turned out good, because it really is amazing dip!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *